Best Eyebrow Pencils of 2025, Expert Reviewed & Tested

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is a best-selling eyebrow pencil that has gained a cult following due to its ease of use and fantastic results. The pencil comes with a no-sharpen wax formula, designed to replicate the look of brow hairs. Available in 12 different shades, it caters to a wide range of hair colors and skin tones.

The thin tip of the pencil is perfect for precise shaping, while the built-in spoolie allows for even product distribution, creating a natural look. Users, especially those with tough-to-match hair colors like gray or silver, swear by its effectiveness, making it a staple in their makeup bags.

The e.l.f. Brow Pencil is a budget-friendly product that doesn’t compromise on quality. This dual-ended pencil comes with both a precision liner and a spoolie, allowing for easy shaping and defining of brows. It has a creamy, smudge-proof formula that leaves a rich pigment, even when applied with slight pressure. It’s also formulated with nourishing ingredients such as grapeseed oil and vitamin E.

Despite its affordable price point, it performs impressively, standing up to more expensive alternatives in the market. However, the limited shade range may not cater to all consumers.

The Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultrafine Shape & Define Pencil stands out in the beauty market for its user-friendly features and reliable performance. Its waterproof formula impressed our testers with its longevity, lasting up to 12 hours without smudging or fading. The pencil’s fine tip allows for precise application, enabling users to add fullness to their brows and layer the product to achieve the desired look.

The 12 available shades cater to all hair colors, ensuring that everyone can find their perfect match. The twist-style pencil, with a built-in spoolie makes brow grooming a breeze and eliminates the need for sharpening. However, daily users may find that the product runs out quickly due to the limited amount of product in the pencil. Despite this, the product’s performance and versatility make it worth buying.

The NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Pomade is a standout product for those with thicker brows looking for a tool to fill in sparse areas. Its creamy formulation glides smoothly, making the application process a breeze. What sets it apart is its dual-ended design, equipped with an angled tip for precision and a fluffy blending brush for an even spread. The shade range is impressive, catering to a variety of skin tones and hair colors.

During our testing, the product demonstrated its ability to stay put throughout the day without smudging, ensuring the brows looked fresh and well-groomed. However, due to its intense pigmentation, a light hand is recommended when creating hair-like strokes. For those seeking a wallet-friendly, high-quality brow pomade, NYX is a reliable choice.

The L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Definer stands out in the market due to its high-quality features and affordable pricing. The ultra-fine tip is perfect for creating thin, hair-like strokes, while the retractable design ensures the pencil never goes dull. Despite its slim design, the pencil delivers intense pigment, although a lighter hand may be necessary to achieve a natural look.

The spoolie at the other end of the pencil seamlessly blends the color, adding to the overall natural effect. The product also impresses with its waterproof quality, ensuring long-lasting wear. It is a highly recommended product, offering great value compared to the more expensive alternatives available in the market.

When it comes to eyebrow grooming, the Charlotte Tilbury Refillable Eyebrow Pencil is exceptional. It effortlessly creates hair-like strokes, thanks to its unique pointed, slightly angled tip. The outcome is similar to microblading at a far lower expense.

The pigment gives a rich yet natural look. Moreover, it has the bonus feature of being refillable, which is a plus for sustainability. Despite its precise tip, the formula does not snap during the application, instead, it glides smoothly over the brows. When not in use, one can retract the tip back into the pencil to protect the formula.

This eyebrow pencil from Selena Gomez’s brand, Rare Beauty, is an editor favorite making waves in the beauty industry since its launch in 2020. The dual-ended pencil features a spoolie for easy fluffing of brows and an angled brow pencil for filling in sparse areas. It gives your brows a long-lasting, naturally feathery appearance.

However, users should be mindful because the soft tip can lead to smudging or over-pigmentation if used heavily. Paired with the brand’s vegan, cruelty-free, and waterproof brow gel, you can achieve a more dramatic brow lamination look.